In 6 linked articles by 6 different news organizations, not ONE talked to a single teenager about the situation. They all have a paternalistic and dehumanizing tone. Teens should be allowed to have large unchaperoned park parties, and they are fully mentally capable of taking necessary actions to make them safe.
We cannot understand what happens during these events that make them wild without listening to teens who were there.
We cannot expect teens who were there to talk to us if we continue to patronize and police them like this.
We cannot develop a city where it is good to be a teenager if we do not hear them out.
This all has been just a frivolous exercise in guess work while the police response to these situations is to arrest children.
When you say “institutions”, do you mean third places?
Because that’s the primary thing that the suburbs killed off for teenagers. Malls were a kind of substitute for quite a while, but the internet killed them off at the same time as it made informal, impromptu organizing more viable for teens.
Seems like this is a simpler symptomatic explanation than “institutions”. The teens literally have nowhere to go to call their own.
Not third places, although I understand the meaning and value of them. We all could use a place to socialize.
I'm talking about the social/cultural/religious organizations that were common. These organizations were often designed with teens in mind, or would often conduct activities for teens and young adults. Clubs, churches, Boy Scouts/Girl Scouts, team or individual sports activities, YMCA/YWCA, community centers, and more.
I'll admit this might sound like an "OK, Boomer" moment from me, but I wasn't thinking of some place necessarily for teens to call their own, as much as places to direct their energy. I think parents had more available for their kids at one time (including third places) but much more is expected for parents to deliver to kids than it used to be. I'm thinking of the resources out there to assist.
Well, we’ve also heavily switched to a helicopter parenting model. That’s not to say that every parent is an extreme helicopter, but rather that the central question of parenting today is whether TO helicopter or not.
If not, you don’t involve them in things; they just sit around at home and don’t go to third places.
To the extent that your answer IS “yes”, you involve them in SOME things or ALL of them, but the point in doing ANYTHING is always some form of social climbing. Membership for membership’s own sake is largely seen as pointless; most members of any institution are there to play status games, whether for internal dominance or external resume-padding.
But again, I do also think that the institutions are only one of several factors. Lack of third places is probably up there with it in the top five.
And moreover, I’d trace it all back up to the suburban lifestyle and development pattern PLUS the NIMBY scourge that came with it. Atomization, isolation, hyper individualism, and car dependency didn’t spawn of their own volition, they were shaped by suburbs. And NIMBY meant delayed and reduced household formation, fertility, and affordability across the board, creating a reinforcing cycle that forced helicopter parenting onto people so their children could make enough money to maintain their social status and standards of living.
It’s never just one thing, it’s always all the things.
As I read what you wrote I agree, except with many caveats. I'd argue "atomization, isolation, hyper individualism and car dependency" come directly from America's rugged individualism ethos, and that created suburbs, too. I think our tendency to partition ourselves makes us less social and sociable. Further, I'd argue that every generation following the "Greatest Generation" that fought WWII has been less social than the one preceding it, and we've lost much of the institutional infrastructure to forestall that. Lastly I'd say it's a cultural issue, not a city/suburb one.
The cultural issue predisposed us to build our suburbs the way we did. Those suburbs then shaped the next directions of our culture. It’s a reinforcing cycle; there is no chicken or egg, but a cycle of evolution.
Some things like those street takeovers where cars do donuts, and the dirt bike groups cruising through town remind me a lot of similar things people did where I grew up in rural Southern Indiana. In my view, those are sort of "boys will be boys" things that are inevitable with teenage and early 20s boys. I'm not saying people should do them, but they are in a well understood genre. The teen takeovers downtown don't directly map to anything in my experience, but are probably a similar phenomenon. The difference is that these have been leading to violence and property destruction, so are harder to just ignore.
These sorts of things need to be addressed given their frequency, but I don't think they are cause for a moral panic.
I'd say that at the idevidual level, family/parenting as well as economics certianly are a big factor in youthful behavior.
But the fact that this sort of thing is such a big issue overall is very much structural as you point out here, and that is something that many (most?) americans dont seem to want to face. This is true across the class spectrum btw, for various reasons. But for many well off suburbanites in particular, the "we have ours already (privatized)" is certianly one major if not the main factor.
Also yes, high crime is nothing new in the US and it has been much worse at times in the past. Yet most seem to be remarkably oblivious of this later fact in my experiance.
This is part of "black flight." Most of Chicago's black youth now live far from the Loop. The Loop is a distant and very different place to the neighborhoods in which they live. The centers of black life are shifting toward Chicago's borders and beyond. Black youth feel that the Loop isn't "theirs" in any sense and going there is going to place from which they feel increasingly excluded. You can't "takeover" a place if its not really yours, which the Loop and central Chicago increasingly are not for blacks.
In 6 linked articles by 6 different news organizations, not ONE talked to a single teenager about the situation. They all have a paternalistic and dehumanizing tone. Teens should be allowed to have large unchaperoned park parties, and they are fully mentally capable of taking necessary actions to make them safe.
We cannot understand what happens during these events that make them wild without listening to teens who were there.
We cannot expect teens who were there to talk to us if we continue to patronize and police them like this.
We cannot develop a city where it is good to be a teenager if we do not hear them out.
This all has been just a frivolous exercise in guess work while the police response to these situations is to arrest children.
When you say “institutions”, do you mean third places?
Because that’s the primary thing that the suburbs killed off for teenagers. Malls were a kind of substitute for quite a while, but the internet killed them off at the same time as it made informal, impromptu organizing more viable for teens.
Seems like this is a simpler symptomatic explanation than “institutions”. The teens literally have nowhere to go to call their own.
Not third places, although I understand the meaning and value of them. We all could use a place to socialize.
I'm talking about the social/cultural/religious organizations that were common. These organizations were often designed with teens in mind, or would often conduct activities for teens and young adults. Clubs, churches, Boy Scouts/Girl Scouts, team or individual sports activities, YMCA/YWCA, community centers, and more.
I'll admit this might sound like an "OK, Boomer" moment from me, but I wasn't thinking of some place necessarily for teens to call their own, as much as places to direct their energy. I think parents had more available for their kids at one time (including third places) but much more is expected for parents to deliver to kids than it used to be. I'm thinking of the resources out there to assist.
Well, we’ve also heavily switched to a helicopter parenting model. That’s not to say that every parent is an extreme helicopter, but rather that the central question of parenting today is whether TO helicopter or not.
If not, you don’t involve them in things; they just sit around at home and don’t go to third places.
To the extent that your answer IS “yes”, you involve them in SOME things or ALL of them, but the point in doing ANYTHING is always some form of social climbing. Membership for membership’s own sake is largely seen as pointless; most members of any institution are there to play status games, whether for internal dominance or external resume-padding.
But again, I do also think that the institutions are only one of several factors. Lack of third places is probably up there with it in the top five.
And moreover, I’d trace it all back up to the suburban lifestyle and development pattern PLUS the NIMBY scourge that came with it. Atomization, isolation, hyper individualism, and car dependency didn’t spawn of their own volition, they were shaped by suburbs. And NIMBY meant delayed and reduced household formation, fertility, and affordability across the board, creating a reinforcing cycle that forced helicopter parenting onto people so their children could make enough money to maintain their social status and standards of living.
It’s never just one thing, it’s always all the things.
As I read what you wrote I agree, except with many caveats. I'd argue "atomization, isolation, hyper individualism and car dependency" come directly from America's rugged individualism ethos, and that created suburbs, too. I think our tendency to partition ourselves makes us less social and sociable. Further, I'd argue that every generation following the "Greatest Generation" that fought WWII has been less social than the one preceding it, and we've lost much of the institutional infrastructure to forestall that. Lastly I'd say it's a cultural issue, not a city/suburb one.
The shortest way I can phrase my retort is this:
The cultural issue predisposed us to build our suburbs the way we did. Those suburbs then shaped the next directions of our culture. It’s a reinforcing cycle; there is no chicken or egg, but a cycle of evolution.
Some things like those street takeovers where cars do donuts, and the dirt bike groups cruising through town remind me a lot of similar things people did where I grew up in rural Southern Indiana. In my view, those are sort of "boys will be boys" things that are inevitable with teenage and early 20s boys. I'm not saying people should do them, but they are in a well understood genre. The teen takeovers downtown don't directly map to anything in my experience, but are probably a similar phenomenon. The difference is that these have been leading to violence and property destruction, so are harder to just ignore.
These sorts of things need to be addressed given their frequency, but I don't think they are cause for a moral panic.
I'd say that at the idevidual level, family/parenting as well as economics certianly are a big factor in youthful behavior.
But the fact that this sort of thing is such a big issue overall is very much structural as you point out here, and that is something that many (most?) americans dont seem to want to face. This is true across the class spectrum btw, for various reasons. But for many well off suburbanites in particular, the "we have ours already (privatized)" is certianly one major if not the main factor.
Also yes, high crime is nothing new in the US and it has been much worse at times in the past. Yet most seem to be remarkably oblivious of this later fact in my experiance.
This is part of "black flight." Most of Chicago's black youth now live far from the Loop. The Loop is a distant and very different place to the neighborhoods in which they live. The centers of black life are shifting toward Chicago's borders and beyond. Black youth feel that the Loop isn't "theirs" in any sense and going there is going to place from which they feel increasingly excluded. You can't "takeover" a place if its not really yours, which the Loop and central Chicago increasingly are not for blacks.